Geoffrey is actually murdered for the a cycling crash inside the 1186 and you may Constance married (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, cuatro th Earl away from Chester, towards step 3 rd March 1188, during the a wedding establish because of the Queen Henry 11. That it marriage deteriorated and you can Ranulph imprisoned Constance when you look at the 1196. Rebellions have been sparked across the Brittany on her and you can Ranulph create their particular from inside the 1198. Back in Brittany, Constance got their particular relationship annulled and later into the 1198, she grabbed People de- Trips once the their particular ‘second’ husband.
Constance passed away old forty, (perhaps regarding leprosy, possibly after giving birth so you’re able to dual girls) for the 5 th September 1201 from the Nantes
The concept that Constance had an affair that have John following the death of Geoffrey and just before John’s wedding to Isabella of Gloucester into the 1189, hence she try mother so you can Joanna is quite controversial and you can has actually provoked much dialogue in this genealogical circles.
From the just having sex that have John, let-alone affect your a child, Constance might have depending a primary-degree matchmaking out-of affinity along with John’s sisters –– plus John’s sibling Geoffrey
One opinion out-of a beneficial genealogist says one ‘this new journal ‘The fresh new Plantagenet Connection’ provides composed an ahnentafel from Age Plantagenet, wife off Henry V11, that provides Joanna’s mother’s identity due to the fact Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess of Brittany. This is actually the Constance who had been John’s sibling-in-rules! Considering the better-identified animosity anywhere between John and you will Constance along with her very own tries to force her son Arthur’s hobbies as much as the latest throne from The united kingdomt is actually alarmed (therefore all know the way disastrously that turned-out!), I truly discover recommended relationship a tiny difficult to consume. The new Constance one record illustrates cannot hit me personally since the into which John can potentially coerce for the sleep.’
‘ A theory who would pick Joanna’s mother because the Constance does not take into account a highly important part of canon law. That would imply that particular shade of one’s count need certainly to definitely have come as a result of you, whether or not it inside it this new request for it, brand new deliberations, or the real dispensation alone. As much as i are aware, nothing of your type can be obtained.’
My own personal advice for what it’s value, would be the fact got Constance been the caretaker from Joanna she’d surely enjoys put their unique upwards in her own household along with her term is too also known as Constance’s most other people because of the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Housemaid of Brittany, Matilda/Maud of Brittany and you can Arthur).
Agatha came to be regarding have a glimpse at the hyperlink 1168 from inside the Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It’s notorious you to definitely she are a mistress off John and lots of family trees give her, regardless if solitary, since mommy of Joanna. Very genealogists although not believe it is merely supposition one this woman is Joanna’s mommy since no facts or information are present to demonstrate which.
Even though this was not an excellent consanguineous dating however, certainly attraction, people first-degree relationship would have made wedding anywhere between Constance and you may any of John’s brothers impossible instead of a good dispensation –– and that considering the party’s review might have was required to come from the latest pope themselves
You to provider seem to offered are Sir William Dugdale, throughout the Baronage out of The united kingdomt (1675-6). He states his provider become Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s job is an enlarged edition of H Lloyd’s interpretation from ‘The new Historie out-of Cambria’ by the a dozen th century Saint Caradoc from Llancarfan. An alternative provider, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ by Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 as well as labels Agatha de Ferrers, child from Robert de- Ferrers, last Earl from derby, as Joanna’s mother.
Although she cannot be totally ignored just like the an applicant to have mommy away from Joanna, definitely there is specific trace out-of their own for the an effective chronicle and other historic source, in the event the she got in fact already been the caretaker of your own wife away from the brand new Prince off Northern Wales.